A Hollywood Republican

This blog is for an open discussion on politics. My views will be to the right as will be most of the posters. But, we are willing to post alternative viewpoints as lons as they are well thought out. I started this in response to the Obama election and will continue it as long as it feeds a need.

Jun 4, 2010

Lieberman/Collins Proposed Bill Giving DHS Emergency Internet Powers by Craig Covello

This week has been full of headlines. The Gulf oil spill has monopolized most of the media's conversation, and justifiably so. There was also the revelation that the senior White House staff adviser Valerie Jarrett and Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel had been subpoenaed in the corruption trial of ex-Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich. And just as the Sestak scandal is heating up, it now appears that White House Deputy Chief of Staff, Jim Messina, made a similar attempt to bribe Andrew Romanoff into dropping his bid for the Democratic Senate race in Colorado. There was also the Israeli attack on Gaza flotilla. Oh, and the Gores have decided to dissolve their 40 year marriage. It's been a busy week.

But the intent of the Obama White House Diaries website (http://www.obamawhitehousediaries.com//) is to try to discover what the left hand of the federal government is doing while we are distracted by the right-hand. You may recall that the Obama White House Diaries published a story on May 6 entitled "Meet Susan Crawford, the White House's Internet Czar". It discussed Crawford's views on Internet regulation, her desire to save the newspapers from declining readership and the federal government's goal to provide subsidized high-speed Internet service to all low income households. She also believes in the concept of "net neutrality", which purports that private sector Internet service providers should not be allowed to create tiered pricing structures based upon content and offerings. Instead, they should be federally regulated as "utilities" with strict price controls. This is analogous to telling Dish Network that it cannot charge a premium for HBO or Showtime. These ideas do not seem to embrace the concept of free enterprise, but then again, neither does the Obama administration.

So it may come as no surprise that senators Joe Lieberman and Susan Collins have drafted a bill which would give the Department of Homeland Security emergency powers over private data networks, including local area networks and servers within companies, based upon a perceived or predicted cyber attack. Specifically, the bill states:

• “The President may issue a declaration of an imminent cyber threat to covered critical infrastructure.”
• DHS's National Center for Cybersecurity and Communications will “develop and coordinate emergency measures or actions necessary to preserve the reliable operation, and mitigate or remediate the consequences of the potential disruption, of covered critical infrastructure.”
• “The owner or operator of covered critical infrastructure shall comply with any emergency measure or action developed by the Director”
• The DHS cybersecurity director has to ensure that the emergency measures “represent the least disruptive means feasible” and that “the privacy and civil liberties of United States persons are protected,”
This bill appears to be another version of similar legislation previously proposed by Senators Jay Rockefeller and Olympia Snowe. In the interest of “national security”, their bill which would have given the federal government the ultimate power to disconnect the Internet. The proposal created such public outrage that it died a quick death. This new bill, however, may get legs.

It naturally begs the question: Is there a problem with the Lieberman/Collins proposal? After all, having a plan to minimize the damage of a cyber attack seems like a noble idea. But perhaps it may not be appropriate when considering the following facts:

• In April, a Pew poll reported that only 22% of Americans surveyed now trust the government in Washington. Almost 33% of those surveyed also believe that the government is a major threat to their personal freedoms and they want a reduction of federal powers.
• This administration has demonstrated an appetite for seizing control of private companies in the face of economic adversity. Sectors include health care, automotive, banking, insurance and student loans. And of course, the federal government now owns over half of the home mortgages in America.
• Despite the positive spin in Obama's press conference last week regarding the Gulf oil spill, the federal government has done an extremely poor job of providing leadership, coordinating efforts and communicating information. Ironically, Washington has been paralyzed in balancing this environmental threat with current EPA legislation and policy. We are now into day 45.
• The Department of Homeland Security has had a difficult time in getting one step ahead of terrorist activity. The Fort Hood massacre, the incompetent underwear bomber and the equally incompetent Times Square bomber immediately come to mind.
Analysis: The proposed cyber bill would give the president power to seize control over private networks based upon his understanding of a perceived security flaw coupled with any rumors of an attack. There are no guidelines associated with either of these determinations. In short, it's simply the president's personal decision whether or not to take over a private companies Internet operations. These emergency measures are supposed to remain in place for no more than 30 days, but they can be extended indefinitely. This unilateral authority is not accountable to Congress or to the Judiciary.

So here's the question: Are you comfortable with that?

© 2010 by Craig Covello. Used with Permission. All Rights Reserved.

Labels: , ,

Feb 2, 2010

NO, NO, They Can't Take That Away from Me by Craig Covello


On December 23rd 2009, the notes on this website reported that Obama conferred diplomatic immunity upon the international police organization known as INTERPOL, effectively making its domestic office records off-limits to US law enforcement, the United States judicial system and even the freedom of information act. Now it looks like the Obama administration has started the process of ceding control of the Internet domain servers to the international community. In effect, this means that an international body will eventually have the power to direct and even restrict Internet traffic. It also opens the door for Internet taxes at an international level. The rationalization for giving up U.S. control of the Internet centers around the idea that the Internet has become so powerful and so vital to international communications that the United States cannot be trusted with its stewardship. Really? Let me point out a few facts.

The Internet was born in the United States. The two Americans working for the Department of defense advanced research project invented in the early 1970s. Their names are Dr. Robert Kahn and Dr. Vinton Cerf. (Sorry Al Gore).

The Internet was based around an open architecture to ensure free and open communications. It was never intended or designed to be censored. Domain servers are spread out across the land and direct traffic, similar to social networking. The concept of centralized Internet control is an oxymoron.

The Chinese government has recently been accused by the United States of hacking into Google accounts of journalists and human rights activists. In response, Google has threatened to pull its operations from China. China has denied the allegations, saying that their constitution guarantees free speech, but with the caveat that they can censor communications that "disrupt public order, impair the health of citizens, or interfere with the educational system of the state". In short, you can say what you want as long as the Chinese government agrees with it.

The Italian prime minister Silvio Berlusconi has also weighed in on Google, which owns YouTube, by pushing legislation which would force Internet service providers to be responsible for any content posted on their servers or be subject to severe fines. You may remember that the 72-year-old prime minister was in the news last year when he was implicated in a sex scandal. This is the guy who is concerned about inappropriate Internet content. It also appears that Italy has plans to further this legislation within the European Union. This is an unprecedented move on freedom of speech and freedom of communication in Europe. Not surprisingly, Italy has one of the lowest Internet usage rates in Western Europe.

True to Obama's style, we watch one hand while the other hand works behind the scenes. Case in point - Hillary Clinton made a speech on January 21 reaffirming our country's position on Internet freedom." Those who disrupt the free flow of information in our society or any other pose a threat to our economy, our government and our civil society. Countries or individuals that engage in cyber attacks should face consequences and international condemnation". So on the one hand, we say we want to protect Internet freedom, freedom of speech and privacy of Internet service provider files. On the other hand, we want to give up control over the Internet to an international body because apparently Americans cannot be trusted. It's as if someone started a company, built it into something magnificent with sweat equity, vision and commitment, only to have some government authority step in and say we don't trust you to run it anymore because it has become too important.

Thank you Mr. Obama. We know that you have faith in America, unless the "international community" disagrees
 
Copyright 2010  by Craig Covello.  Used with Permission.  All rights reserved.

Labels: , , , ,

Nov 24, 2009

Telegraph or The Internet by Craig Covello


A story was published November 21, 2009 on Fox news regarding memoranda hacked from a British climate research center.  At least one of these stolen emails suggested plans to hide data which could contradict current political policy for controlling carbon emissions.  It unfortunately showed a decline in temperatures which is at odds with the new global warming drumbeat.  Whether or not the e-mail was taken out of context, this incident definitely gave me pause to think about something that I find intuitively obvious.  Although some may not agree, I believe the following -

This is probably the worst possible time in all of recorded history to try to hide the truth because of....THE INTERNET

Our "information age" has gone into hyper-drive over the past few years.  We now have Twitter, Face Book, Google Sites, SMS text messaging, instant messaging, Skype, iChat and You Tube.  I personally have two cell phones, a pager and four computers (including a Mac).  Our great grandparents had:  the telegraph and carrier pigeons.  Given this remarkable advancement in technology, wouldn't it seem reasonable that it is much more difficult to tell a lie or suppress the truth these days?  This premise is based upon several assumptions -
1. We are paying attention to credible, investigative news sources (I think there are one or two left).
2. We have some common sense which the politically correct crowd probably finds neanderthal and offensive.
3. We know how to use a computer to surf the Internet.
4. We are not lazy.

5. We are not afraid to express our opinions in a public forum and respectfully disagree with others.

6. The Internet will not be shut down by the federal government.
Items one through five don't have me worried.  Item six, however, is another story.  All of us have been empowered to create, store and transport tremendous amounts of data, including pictures and even video.  We can send it to virtually anyone in the world for free.  Amazing stuff.  But this newly found communications empowerment is now at odds with the liberal agenda.  Americans are talking to each other like never before both locally and across great distances.  And the more we know about the current state of American politics, the more we are alarmed.  Free and open communication is clearly a threat to the small group of radicals currently working in the White House who want to control virtually every aspect of our lives.  Perhaps this is why Senate bill #773 was introduced by Senator John Rockefeller.  It would give the federal government legal right to shut down the Internet at its discretion under the guise of "national security".  Sounds a little like China, doesn't it?  Maybe that's why Anita Dunn finds comfort in the teachings of Chairman Mao.

There is, however, one factor that I don't think Anita or the rest of this administration understands.  Our country was founded on the concept of individual freedom.  Freedom of association, freedom of expression, freedom of religion, freedom to own property and the freedom to make our own decisions and live with the consequences.

It was not founded to redistribute wealth, to bail out large corporations, to protect others from being offended, to enslave us in debt or to keep us in the dark.  We will not be kept in the dark.  We will not be blissfully ignorant.  We will not be afraid to ask relevant questions regarding the truth about our government's actions and motives.

Yes, I concede that:

Technical advancement in communications has made it easier to facilitate propaganda.  That's true, but the sword cuts both ways.  It is has also become much easier to root out bogus information.  We can now cross check questionable content using multiple sources in a matter of minutes.  It used to take days, weeks or months.

Private key encryption can be used to suppress information, even if "inquiring minds want to know."  Again, that's true, but all security systems have one vulnerability:  PEOPLE.  If there are one or more dissenters in the secure communication chain, they can always forward information in the clear.  It's called "copy/paste" and requires two keystrokes.  As with other forms of social networks, trust is built over time and credibility will be lost for those who disseminate misinformation.  That said, "copy/paste" is the new Gutenberg press.

I'm sure that Gutenberg never envisioned the power of video.  You may be old enough to remember some Haitian history in which occurred in 1984.  At that time, Jean-Claude "Baby-Doc" Duvalier and his wife Michele thought it was a good idea to televise a lavish May gala ball to the Haitian economically impoverished by setting up government-owned color television in the villages.  It was a big mistake.  Itentionally sharing the display of opulent wealth to starving people caused an uprising which eventually led to an overthrow of the dictatorship.  The Haitian people revolted because they knew too much.  The flames were further fanned by the arrogance of the government.

Sound familiar?  The Obama crowd has been rather arrogant themselves, but unlike the Duvalier's "in-your-face" public display, this administration has chosen to downplay government transparency.  After all, who needs a meddlesome constituency asking questions and raising objections that might get in the way of a liberal, if not communist agenda.

The trend may be shifting soon.  Thanks to the conservative Internet forums, blogs and news sources, we know too much.  Acorn, Van Jones, Mark Lloyd, Kevin Jennings and Anita Dunn are good examples.  Have you seen the US debt clock? http://www.usdebtclock.org/  The federal deficit is now more than $100,000 per taxpayer.  I did not know that a year ago.  And then there's the clips on You Tube, one of which shows manufacturing czar Ron Bloom proclaiming that the free market is "nonsense."  The list goes on and on, most recently with the administration's decision to try the 9/11 Muslim radical terrorists in New York while granting them the same legal rights afforded to U.S.citizens.

So here's the point.  This isn't Chicago in the 1920s.  The telegraph is out.  The Internet is in.  If the Obama administration believes it can stealthily operate behind the scenes ignoring the Constitution in order to bring about radical change that the majority of Americans find unacceptable, they are mistaken.  Just try shutting down the Internet and see what happens.   e.g. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sIFYPQjYhv8

Copyright 2009 by Craig Covello.  Used with Permission.  All rights reserved
3TFA3VTGPZTF

Labels: , , , ,

Oct 23, 2009

"When Pigs Fly" by Ira Schwartz


Senator John Rockefeller’s Internet Bill S.773 has been winding its way around Capitol Hill for the last few months. Below is the Governments brief description of the bill.

“A bill to ensure the continued free flow of commerce within the United States and with its global trading partners through secure cyber communications, to provide for the continued development and exploitation of the Internet and intranet communications for such purposes, to provide for the development of a cadre of information technology specialists to improve and maintain effective cyber security defenses against disruption, and for other purposes.

The Bill directs the Secretary of Commerce to develop or coordinate a national licensing, certification, and recertification program for cyber security professionals and makes it unlawful to provide certain cyber security services without being licensed and certified. Requires Advisory Panel approval for renewal or modification of a contract related to the operation of the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority. Requires development of a strategy to implement a secure domain name addressing system. Requires the National Science Foundation (NSF) to support specified types of research and to establish a program of grants to higher education institutions to establish cyber security test beds.”

You got all that…good. Now if all that doesn’t upset you this will. S 773 also allows the Secretary of Commerce access to all privately owned information networks deemed to be critical to the nation's infrastructure "without regard to any provision of law, regulation, rule or policy restricting such access."

In other words it allows our government free access to all information, private or public, available over the internet, secure or unsecure, whenever “they” deem it necessary regardless of how many laws they are breaking and regardless of the constitution. An internet “Get out of jail for free” card that never expires.

Leslie Harris, president of the Center for Democracy and Technology, said, "The cyber security threat is real. But such a drastic federal intervention in private communications technology and networks could harm both security and privacy."

S 773 basically says the President has the authority, in the event of a cyber attack, to disconnect "critical infrastructure" networks from the Internet – including private citizens' banks and health records. The problem is the bill fails to explain what exactly a “cyber attack” is.

Also the bill give the Department of Commerce the authority to monitor private information networks deemed a part of the "critical infrastructure. The feds get to look through your health and financial records whenever they want to without a warrant. Where’s that Bill of Rights? I know I had it here just a minute ago. I’ll bet the constitutional attorneys are salivating over that one.

Also to be one of the “Cyber Security Professionals” you will have to be licensed by the Government. Sure why not…lets just give all the keys to the chicken coop to the wolves. And while we’re at it lets create “another government agency” and name another “czar” to run it. We’ll just print more money to pay for it…or is it borrow more money from China, Medicare or Social Security.

Larry Seltzer, software developer, who has written articles for such magazines as Fortune Small Business, Windows 2000 Magazine (now Windows and .NET Magazine), ZDNet and Sam Whitmore's Media Survey, said in an interview for eWeek, "The whole thing smells bad to me. I don't like the chances of the government improving this situation by taking it over generally, and I definitely don't like the idea of politicizing this authority by putting it in the direct control of the president. Let's think about this," continues Seltzer. "I'm especially curious as to how you take the telecommunications networks off of the Internet when they are, in large part, what the Internet is comprised of. And if my bank were taken offline, I would think about going into my branch and asking for all of my deposits in cash."

P.S. So would I.

According to the Center for Democracy and Technologies senior counsel, Greg Nojeim, in an interview with” Mother Jones”, “This bill would undermine the Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA). That law, (ECPA) enacted in the mid '80s, requires law enforcement seek a warrant before tapping in to data transmissions between computers.” OOPPSS…How convenient.

Over the last 30 years the internet has become an integral source of communication and information for the whole world. When China suppresses sections of the internet we are quick to scream about “human rights” violations yet right now in our own backyard our representatives are preparing to do the same thing under the guise of security.

I know I’ve used this quote from Ben Franklin before but we seem to have the need to constantly be reminded of this. “Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.”

A few years ago a legislator, who requested the reporter not use his name, was asked about the possibility of the government placing restrictions on the internet. The legislator chuckled then responded, “Yeah right Son, when pigs fly.”

What’s that flapping sound I hear?

© 2009 by Ira Schwartz. Printed with permission of the author.

Labels: , , , , , , ,