A Hollywood Republican

This blog is for an open discussion on politics. My views will be to the right as will be most of the posters. But, we are willing to post alternative viewpoints as lons as they are well thought out. I started this in response to the Obama election and will continue it as long as it feeds a need.

Oct 27, 2009

SAG and The Independent


A few months ago I wrote a column about the effect IATSE’s wage increase in Michigan would have on future production in Michigan. Just recently, the company I have my first look deal with decided to produce another picture in Michigan and was informed my column made it impossible for IATSE to negotiate or help us in any way. They basically said this is the deal, take it or leave it if you want to shoot here; your employee ruined it for you.

My company then proceeded to disavow any knowledge of my column and said that what I write is of my own doing and not the policy of the company. This is true. It is my own doing. No one tells me what to write or censors my editorial content.

I still believe IATSE is harming the burgeoning film industry in Michigan. I believe that if IATSE was doing the right thing in Michigan, the state of Michigan would be putting all of the other tax incentive states out of business. Producers would be running there in droves.

Unions are supposed to be the mechanism to level the playing field for the working man. Their job is to protect the working man from “the man,” and to keep their members employed fairly. Isn’t employment what unions are really all about: Especially now when unemployment is so rampant all over the United States particularly in Michigan and California. You would think the unions would be bending over backwards to work with “the man” in a mutually beneficial situation. Let us all do whatever is necessary to keep employment in the United States; not Eastern Europe or Asia.

Unfortunately, this is not the case with IATSE in Michigan and with the Screen Actors Guild (SAG) anywhere. SAG does their best to stop movies from being made instead of helping the independent producer hire their mass of unemployed.

I will now give some examples of how SAG harms the independent. My first look deal is with Nu Image, Inc., one of, if not largest independent production companies in the business. In the last 10 years, this company has produced more than 150 films ranging in size from one million dollars to sixty million dollars. It has employed more than 1,000 actors; the majority of which are members of SAG.

Does SAG do anything to make life easier for this company? No. SAG does everything in their power to stop this company from making movies. In fact, over the past ten years, there have been many incidents where this company has had to threaten to shut a movie down and sue SAG in order to get any cooperation whatsoever.

This is a company that employs, pay actors millions of dollars and pays residuals to actors on a regular basis. Can you tell me one true independent that has been doing this since 1992? Probably not!

Just last week, Nu Image was about to shoot a thirty million dollar film and was held hostage the day before principal photography was to start over a dispute regarding the SAG Bond which is a “guarantee” that actors will be paid. SAG insisted on a bond in the approximate amount of $400,000 which was based upon erroneous SAG employment figures provided by the production staff on location. SAG did not care. They were going to call actors’ agents and shut the movie down the day before it was scheduled to start. The matter was resolved at the twenty-fourth hour, but not before threats were made from both sides that almost put the picture in jeopardy. At one point, a SAG employee told us, well if a production employee provided erroneous figures, you should fire him/her. Is this the way a union represents workers?

Another nightmare for the independent producer is the SAG security interest which is a lien on the film’s copyright for the life of the copyright. The theory behind this is to protect the actors against unscrupulous producers failing to pay residuals. Fine. It makes sense for one-off producers or producers with a bad reputation. But, is it necessary for a major independent production company with a history of paying residuals? Why must SAG demand cash - which is desperately needed to fund the production – be removed from the budget to pay SAG deposits? Why must the threats go back and forth every time any request is made?

Then after all of the stress with SAG during production, the independent must beg for the return of the SAG Bond after it has paid the actors in full. As you already know, this amount of cash can be substantial and for smaller companies is actually needed to complete the movie. Thank God, Nu Image has the capability to complete movies without this money. I have heard horror stories from other companies where the SAG bond has caused foreclosure on loans and investor liens because sometimes they will just not return it. Sometimes they unilaterally convert it to a residuals bond to guarantee the payment of residuals. Doesn’t that amount to conversion?

Sometimes the reason given for its non-return is absolutely asinine. For example, SAG has a document that must be completed on every film to show minority hiring. You must show the number of females and people of color hired by the production. This form is a survey and nothing more. There are no quotas in the SAG system and a producer may hire whoever they choose. However, if this form is not filed by the producer, the bond is not returned. The same is true of every piece of paper that SAG employees have on their checklist. No one will think out of the box. No one will pull the trigger and give the money back until this checklist is complete.

And, no one will give the money back with any interest that matters. Back in the day when CD’s were paying 4-5%, SAG was paying 1.5% or less on the bond. I’m sure now they are holding money in some cases for more than a year and paying 0% interest. I wonder what they do with the money they earn?

Lastly, the SAG arbitration system must be discussed. Talk about an uneven playing field! Prior to producing films, I was an entertainment attorney. In all, I have been in the business for 25 years give or take. During that time, I have not seen one SAG arbitration ruled in favor of the producer. In fact, some arbitrators on the SAG list have never ruled in favor of management. I can think of a few names that are on my strike list just because of personal experiences.

In one circumstance, a former SAG Board member, Seymour Cassel was hired by a company that I was involved with. Mr. Cassel, being on the SAG Board forced the union to pursue a grievance on his behalf. That matter was fairly simple. He believed he had a two week guarantee of employment and the employer felt there was no guarantee and paid him for the one week he actually worked.

The matter went to arbitration and Mr. Cassel won. He was given the second week. It seems like it should have been a swearing contest and the arbitrator just chose to believe the representatives of Mr. Cassel. Sorry, nope.

It was much more complicated than that. Mr. Cassel had actually signed both a SAG deal memo and a long form agreement, neither of which mentioned anything about a guarantee. In fact, they specifically stated there was no guarantee. But, there was an interoffice memo from Mr. Cassel’s agent that said the deal was for a two week guarantee. This document was not signed by anybody. In legal parlance, it not only was pure hearsay, but it violated the merger rule. It should not even have been entered into evidence.

This did not matter to the arbitrator, he ruled for Mr. Cassel based upon the interoffice memo.

By the way, Mr. Cassel was just thrown off the SAG Board last week for “conduct unbecoming a member,” and his membership was suspended. (Daily Variety – October 20, 2009). In the Daily Variety article, it stated that Mr. Cassel was considering filing for “financial core” status which would permit him to work on union and non-union films during the course of his suspension.

“Financial Core” is a really interesting animal. It is based upon a Supreme Court decision (Communications Workers of America v. Beck, 487 U.S. 735 (1988)) in which a union member sued the union because he did not want to be associated with the Union’s political lobbying activities. The Supreme Court found for the union member and stated that no one could be obligated to pay for the political positions of the union. They only had to be obligated to pay union dues for the “financial core” of the union.

Based on this Supreme Court ruling, any member of any union in the country can go “Financial Core.” All it requires is that they write a one sentence letter to their union stating that they have elected Financial Core membership. A “Financial Core” member of any union is still covered by all union benefits such as pension, health and welfare. They can then work on all union and non-union movies without being subject to any penalty from the union at all. The only things a “Financial Core” member of a union cannot do is vote in union elections or hold elected positions within the union.

Personally I am amazed that droves of actors, directors, writers and crew members have not chosen Financial Core membership. Maybe it’s because the unions all try to keep it a total secret and will do almost anything to avoid their members becoming aware of its benefits. Imagine – union members being able to decide for themselves who they will work for and under what conditions. It would mean they have to be treated as adults - not obedient children by their unions! It would certainly make life easier for independent producers and allow them to spend their hard won cash on making movies not paying for union bureaucracies. Maybe Seymour Cassel will start a trend – who knows! It may even help the employment situation for actors and all member of the entertainment industry. After all, isn’t that what we need to end this recession; more employment!

©2009 by Frank T. DeMartini. Permission to copy will be freely granted upon request.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

Oct 21, 2009

Where is California’s Representation?


I have been a California resident for the past 23 years. During that time, I have seen the best of times and worst of times. Prior to this economic disaster, the only serious recession in those 23 years was in 1991-1992. At that time, myself and many others in similar situations faced economic turmoil. However, nothing comes close to what is happening now in what used to be the greatest State in the union.


According to the most recent reports, the unemployment rate in California has reached 12.2%. The rate in Los Angeles County is at 12.7%. Some cities within the county such as Compton and Commerce are over 20%. These are all far worse than the national rate of 9.8%.

What makes these numbers even scarier is that they have not hit rock bottom according to economic estimates at both the state and federal level. In fact, the State Government estimate of a maximum unemployment rate of 12.8% seems like it is going to be topped shortly, probably by early winter. Is it possible that California’s unemployment rate will top the number in 1940 of 14.7% which is the highest recorded on record?

All of these numbers really do not mean anything unless you compare them to other numbers in the country to get a real picture of just how bad things are here right now. The California rate is currently the fourth worst in the country. The only one significantly worse is Michigan at 15.2%. Notice any similarities between the two by the way? Not much except maybe extremely powerful unions in both!

And, on top of all this, the economy is primed to get much worse. When I drive down the streets in Los Angeles, I see nothing but empty storefronts on all major boulevards. Portions of Laurel Canyon Blvd have four to five empty storefronts on each block. Ventura Blvd., Wilshire Blvd., and Sunset Blvd are not fairing much better. And, I am told it is worse in other parts of the state.

According to some reports, the only real estate changing hands here are foreclosures and estate sales. Banks are not even evicting foreclosed owners in some parts of the Inland Empire because they want the house to be saleable when the economy finally does turn around. I mean, who wants to purchase a foreclosed house that has been destroyed by vandals. I know of one particular situation where a family has made no mortgage payments since May, 2007 and is still living in the house free of rent or tax payments.

Are there any solutions to this problem? Is there any quick fix? Or, must we just wait it out in hope that this Great State will make a comeback? I really do not believe any of the Federal Stimulus money will help the California job market. It has done nothing so far except allow some families to survive with the extension of unemployment benefits. It is definitely not helping the ailing real estate or worsening job market. If anything, the excessive federal spending is hurting the economy.

And, what have our representatives in Congress done to help us? Nancy Pelosi does nothing accept cost the US and California jobs with her constant big government, regulatory, liberal agenda. Her support of “Cap and Trade” and HR 3200 will not only effect the US Economy on the whole, but will have a double impact on the state of California. Outsourcing is already a problem here, but it will get much worse if either of these bills become law. In fact, it seems that there is already evidence that California employers are not hiring until the result of both “Cap and Trade” and health care reform are known.

The same goes for Barbara Boxer and Diane Feinstein. Neither of them are doing anything to support the economy in the state. They are just following the same liberal agenda regardless of how it affects the people of California.

One prime example is that there is not one Congressman representing Californians doing anything to overturn the Federal Order which stopped irrigation in the Sacramento area after it was ruled the necessary irrigation had caused the Delta Smelt, a small fish, to become endangered. This has caused the farming industry in the Sacramento and Fresno area to pretty much come to a standstill and bring the unemployment rate in the area to approximately 17%. In fact, the city of Mendota has an unemployment rate of 41%, the highest in the country. (That’s right 41%. It’s not a typo.)

Comedian Paul Rodriguez, a former Democrat and Obama supporter, whose family are farmers in the area, has left his liberal roots as a result of this fiasco. He has now appeared on Sean Hannity’s show stating that the entire area is in extreme danger. Farms are being lost, unemployment is rampant and people are starving: All to protect a little two inch fish.

And what do our Senators and Representatives in California do about this; again, absolutely nothing. It seems it is more important to protect the Delta Smelt than to protect the people of the Central Valley. Let the people starve and the fish thrive. Who cares if 80,000 people in the area are unemployed? If they can not afford bread, let them eat cake.

That is the whole problem with the current Administration and Congress in Washington and the State Legislature in Sacramento, including the aforementioned Ms. Pelosi, Ms. Boxer, and Ms. Feinstein, as well as, Mr. Waxman, Ms. Waters, Ms. Watson and the favorite of this column, Mr. Dan Lungren. They simply do not care about the people, economy or problems of the State. They care only about the special interest groups that finance and support them.

I am reminded of “Legally Blonde 2” in which Elle’s boss, the Congresswomen, stabbed Elle in the back because a strong campaign financer was against the proposed animal rights bill. It is true whether it be fact or fiction.

In the end, the free market will bring this State back to its former glory provided that the regulators and liberals currently in control, including the Obama Administration and his cabinet, do not destroy it completely. The people of California must rise up against their current so called Representatives and do whatever is necessary to take our government back so that it is a government of the people and for the people, not for the governors!

© 2009 by Frank T. DeMartini. Permission to copy will be granted freely upon request.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,